How to compare management institutes on placements, practical learning, and career growth
If you are looking for a MBA and PGDM ROI in Pune with good placements and ROI, start with three questions:
- What will the programme cost you in full?
- What kinds of jobs do graduates actually join?
- What will you learn to do that can help you grow after the first job?
Campus placement data can answer part of the second question. To answer the third, ask to see the work students do and follow what graduates go on to do with it.
Imagine two students accepting campus offers on the same day. Both have paid ₹6 lakh for their management programme. Both have an offer that says ₹6 lakh a year. At the placement celebration, the arithmetic looks reassuring. The fee and the package match. It is tempting to say the investment will be recovered in a year.
One student joins, settles into the role, and gradually takes responsibility for more difficult work. The other joins, and the job ends after one month. The placement announcement still records two offers at ₹6 lakh. The graduates and their families have had two very different experiences. Which of those experiences does the advertised return on investment capture?
I have been asking this question for a long time because I believe management institutes owe students and parents a fuller account of the return on their investment. A first offer matters. It can change the immediate prospects of a student who has never had access to that employer or that kind of role.
But when an institute divides a starting package by its fees and presents the result as ROI, it gives the family an incomplete picture when they’re deciding how much to spend, how much to borrow, and what two years of study are worth.
My term for the fuller return is lasting ROI. It includes the financial gain a student actually earns over time. It includes the ability to sustain employment, recover from a setback, earn colleagues’ trust and grow into greater responsibility. It also includes the value that a capable graduate creates for an employer, a family and, over many years, the city and country in which that person works.
Those outcomes need different kinds of evidence. Together, they give us a better idea of what we are investing in when we choose management education.
What a full return includes
Return on investment, in its financial sense, measures the net gain from a decision relative to what it cost. For an MBA or PGDM, the gain is the extra income the student actually earns over a stated period compared with a realistic alternative.
The investment is the full cost of choosing the programme, including the earnings the student gives up while studying. Dividing an advertised salary by tuition leaves out both the alternative and most of what happens after joining.
For lasting ROI, I want four things to be visible:
- The financial return and how long it takes to recover the investment.
- The durability of the career, including whether the graduate completes probation, sustains employment, moves for growth, recovers from a setback, and earns promotions or wider responsibilities.
- The graduate’s contribution at work, including how well they diagnose problems, work across teams, earn trust, and deliver improvements people use.
- The value that continues after the job, through a more secure household, better-run local enterprises and stronger organisations across the country.
I would look for evidence on each of these. The institute’s curriculum, faculty, mentoring and practical work tell us how it prepares students to achieve them.
What I mean by a career that lasts
Earnings are one part of the return. I would also look at a graduate’s capacity to remain useful as work changes. Did they complete probation? Can they handle an assignment independently? When the company changes a system or enters a new market, can they learn what the new work requires? When their department has a problem, do colleagues involve them in solving it? Those questions are more revealing than the number of years on a particular payroll.
Promotion matters, especially when it brings responsibility for people, decisions, budgets, or customers. Its timing varies by employer and industry. A graduate whose title remains unchanged may be running a larger territory, negotiating with more complex clients, or training new colleagues. I would record those changes as well as formal promotions. I would also look at whether people who move jobs can explain what they learned, why they moved, and whether the new role gives them room to grow.
People sometimes ask whether a graduate is liked at work. I would look for something more specific. Do colleagues trust this person to keep a commitment? Do they share information that others need to do their jobs? When a project goes wrong, can they acknowledge their part and help put it right? Can they disagree with a colleague without damaging the working relationship? These qualities show up in conduct. A manager can describe what the graduate did, and colleagues can say whether they would trust that person with a difficult assignment again.
Involvement is another sign. A graduate who understands how their work affects a customer, another team, or the organisation’s costs is more likely to notice issues that fall between job descriptions. Involvement takes many forms. Someone in finance can flag a cash-flow risk before it becomes a crisis. Someone in HR can discover why new employees are leaving. Someone in supply chain can spot the pattern behind late deliveries. I would count a graduate’s ability to take an issue seriously, follow it through, and involve the right people as part of the return on their education.
Institutes can prepare students for these situations. Employers determine the quality of the roles and the support people receive once hired. Graduates make their own choices about effort, learning, and what they want from work. Economic conditions matter too. When we follow graduates, we should account for those differences. An institute can still be held to a demanding standard for what it puts in place while students are on campus.
The return that reaches the people around the graduate
For the organisation, value may start with a graduate who can make one process work better. Consider a new manager who sees a pattern in customer complaints and discovers that the service team is repeatedly asking customers for documents the company already holds. Fixing that handover could reduce work for colleagues and inconvenience for customers. Over time, that same manager can develop others who know how to observe a process, test a change, and learn from the result. The institute’s contribution keeps showing up long after the first job if that habit travels with the graduate.
For a family, the return can be both immediate and gradual. Sustained earnings can help repay an education loan, support a parent or create room for a sibling to study. Better financial judgement can help a household make decisions about borrowing or plan for a period of uncertainty. Families make different sacrifices to pay for education. A student should be able to weigh the financial risk before admission and have a realistic chance of improving the family’s position after graduation.
A city benefits when people with management skills improve the organisations that operate there. A graduate can help a local manufacturer reduce waste, help a small business collect payments on time, or build a service that employs people in the neighbourhood. In a city such as Pune, the opportunity extends across different kinds of organisations. A graduate who learns to solve a problem in a modest firm may later bring the same method to a supplier, a civic organisation or a business of their own. These contributions can be small individually and still matter to the people affected by them.
For India, I think of management education as an investment in people who will carry responsibility for decades. They will run operations, allocate resources, train teams, start companies, and decide how customers and employees are treated. A graduate who improves an organisation’s productivity while building a fair and dependable workplace contributes something that can outlast their tenure. When graduates pass on what they know, the return can continue through the people they train and the institutions they build. That is what I mean when I say we are creating a resource for the country for much of a working life, with effects that can last even longer.
Those wider contributions can be documented through employer evidence, alumni accounts and examples of jobs created or improvements sustained. I would report them alongside the financial return. Trying to convert every contribution to a family, city or employer into a rupee figure would give an impression of accuracy that the evidence rarely supports.
How to read MBA and PGDM placement reports
A placement report should help families understand the opportunity an institute can open up. Employers may visit a campus because the placement team has built a relationship with them over years. They may return because previous graduates have performed well, or because the institute helps them find a group of candidates with the right background.
The students still have to earn the offer. The institute deserves credit for making the opportunity accessible.
I cannot know the details of every arrangement between an institute and its recruiters. The relevant question for a parent is what happened after the interview:
- How many students received offers?
- How many actually joined?
- What roles did they enter?
- What were their responsibilities?
- Did the institute report the number of offers or the number of individual students placed?
If one student receives three offers, a count of three offers tells us something about employer activity. A family trying to understand the prospects of a typical student needs the number of people who actually entered employment.
The same care applies to the package. A ₹6 lakh cost-to-company figure may include fixed pay, variable compensation, benefits, or payments conditional on staying for a specified period. A family paying a loan instalment needs to know what money reaches the graduate’s account and when.
A student deciding whether to relocate needs to know the fixed component, the location, the cost of living and the conditions attached to the variable component. Ask for the median fixed pay for a defined batch and an explanation of whom it covers. A large offer to one student has little bearing on how the rest of the batch financed its education.
I object to the way these figures are sometimes presented. A placement headline can be factually accurate and still mislead if it implies a return the data cannot establish. If an institute wants to advertise a starting package, it should tell families what the figure measures, which students it covers, and where the information ends. That is particularly important when the headline accompanies a request for a substantial, largely irreversible fee payment.
What happens if the first job ends in a month
Return to the student with a ₹6 lakh offer. Suppose, for illustration, that the entire ₹6 lakh is fixed annual gross pay, that it accrues evenly and that the student receives exactly one month of pay. The student has earned ₹50,000 gross from that job. The remaining eleven months of the quoted salary have yet to be earned.
If the student takes four months to find the next job, those months belong in the record. If the next job pays more, that belongs in the record too. The financial return depends on the subsequent career, so we cannot settle it on the day the offer is announced or even the day the first job ends.
There are many reasons a job might end early. A company may restructure. The advertised role may differ from what the graduate finds on arrival. A new manager may have different expectations. A graduate may struggle with the work, or decide to leave for a more suitable role. It would be unfair to take every early departure as proof that the institute failed. It would also be a mistake to leave departures out of the evidence altogether. An institute interested in outcomes should want to know what happened and whether a pattern is emerging.
For instance:
- If graduates in one type of role repeatedly struggle to meet basic reporting requirements, the institute can look at the training and the way it prepares students for that role.
- If students leave because they discover a job advertised as marketing consists mainly of field sales, the institute can explain the role more clearly before students accept it.
- If departures are due to a company closure, the practical question is how quickly graduates can find new work and what support is available to them.
This is where longevity matters. I want a graduate to be able to hold a job, learn from it and take on more responsibility. I also want that person to have the judgement and the skills to move when a role has run its course. Someone who leaves after a year for a better role may be making more progress than someone who stays in the same seat for five years. The outcome I would look for is sustained employability, with enough detail to understand why people stay, move or find themselves out of work.
What we would pay for if placement were the whole service
Consider the logic of treating education primarily as a way to secure a first job. Suppose someone could obtain a suitable recognised qualification for ₹1 lakh to ₹1.5 lakh and then seek work directly, through referrals or with the help of a recruitment agency. Those figures are illustrative. The route may open different doors, and the student would have to check the qualification, eligibility for target roles, and actual costs.
Even so, the comparison asks a fair question. If the only outcome an institute can explain is an introduction to an employer, what does the rest of a ₹15 lakh, ₹20 lakh or ₹25 lakh education buy?
Some Indian recruitment firms publish an employer fee of 8.33% of annual CTC, roughly one-twelfth of that amount, with the fee invoiced when a candidate joins. On a ₹6 lakh CTC, that is about ₹50,000 before applicable taxes. The published terms illustrate one commercial model. The hiring company is the client in these examples, and the rate and payment terms depend on the contract.
I am using the example to put a price on a recruitment service. Students should understand who pays before accepting any recruitment arrangement. The International Labour Organization’s fair recruitment guidance says that recruitment fees and related costs should not be borne by workers or jobseekers.
The point is worth making bluntly. If all I wanted was access to a vacancy, I would examine the direct hiring route and what recruiters can do before I committed two years and a large sum of money to management education. An institute should welcome that comparison. It gives the institute a chance to explain the value of its teaching, the work students do during the programme and the development they take into subsequent jobs. A rigorous course can be worth paying for. Its case rests on what the student will learn and be able to carry into an organisation.
A recruitment firm can assess a candidate against a brief and bring two parties together. The work of a management institute spans a different period in a person’s life. Over two years, it can give a student repeated opportunities to tackle a problem, make a judgement under uncertainty, work with people whose priorities differ, receive feedback and try again. It can teach the student to see consequences that were invisible before. If an institute does those things well, the student can benefit long after everyone has forgotten the first placement package.
How to calculate MBA or PGDM ROI over five years
Start by defining what the decision costs the student. There is the fee on the brochure, and there is the full amount the family will commit.
- Add compulsory charges, relocation, additional living expenses, and the interest the student will pay if borrowing.
- Subtract scholarships.
- Include income the student could reasonably have earned during the course. A graduate who was already earning ₹5 lakh a year faces a different decision from someone who had no comparable work opportunity.
- Use the additional living cost of studying away from home, because the student would have had living expenses on the other route as well.
- Count the tuition once, even when it is paid through a loan. Interest and fees are borrowing costs. Loan principal is the means of paying the expense already counted.
Then choose a period, such as five years after graduation. Calculate what the person actually earned in that period, including periods out of work and any bonus that was actually paid. Use the same basis for both scenarios, ideally earnings after tax if the aim is to understand what the family gained.
Estimate what the same person could have earned over those years without enrolling. That alternative might be staying in a current job, joining a different programme, or taking up a role available after an undergraduate degree. A single assumption can flatter either choice, so it is worth testing a lower and a higher estimate for that alternative.
The financial calculation I would use is straightforward.
Five-year financial ROI = [(Five-year earnings with the programme − estimated five-year earnings without it − total education investment) ÷ total education investment] × 100.
Use earnings forgone during the years of study in the investment figure and compare earnings only over the years after graduation in the first two terms. That keeps the same loss of income from being counted twice. For a more detailed assessment, allow for the timing of fees, interest, and earnings. A rupee received several years from now does not have the same value as a rupee paid today.
Suppose the total investment is ₹10 lakh. Over five years after graduation, a student earns ₹40 lakh. Based on the jobs available before admission and a realistic estimate of progression, suppose the alternative would have produced ₹24 lakh over the same five years. The incremental earnings are ₹16 lakh. After subtracting the ₹10 lakh investment, the net gain is ₹6 lakh and the illustrative five-year ROI is 60%.
If the alternative would have produced ₹30 lakh, the same programme and the same actual career would yield a financial ROI of 0%. The decision looks different depending on the opportunity the student gave up.
Now consider two graduates with the same ₹10 lakh investment and the same estimated ₹20 lakh in alternative earnings. One begins at ₹8 lakh a year and earns ₹32 lakh over five years. The other begins at ₹6 lakh and earns ₹40 lakh over the period. In this illustration, their financial returns are 20% and 100%, respectively. A starting package comparison would have favoured the first graduate. The five-year calculation changes the answer because it accounts for earnings as they occur.
I would also ask when the student breaks even. In this framework, financial payback occurs when cumulative additional earnings cover the full education investment.
The household cash-flow question is separate. A graduate may be on course to earn a positive return over five years and still struggle to make loan payments in the first year. A family needs to see whether it can manage delayed joining, a period on reduced income, or a salary with a large variable component. The cost of education is borne in real time, and the return arrives unevenly.
Every figure estimated before admission is a projection. It is useful if the assumptions are clear and a family can change them. The strongest institute data would show the distribution of actual outcomes from comparable cohorts, so students can see how people with similar backgrounds fared. A five-year projection for an individual should never be presented as a promise by the institute.
A problem located is a problem solved
I often say, “A problem located is a problem solved.” I mean that identifying the real problem makes a useful solution possible. Doing this well is one of the harder tasks in management. People describe what hurts from where they sit. A sales manager sees a missed target. The warehouse sees an increase in urgent orders. Finance sees overdue payments. Each has a piece of the story. A student who can listen to all three, follow the evidence and work out where the process breaks has done work of real value before proposing a single tool.
Imagine a business that asks a group of students to increase sales. The group could immediately prepare a campaign. It could also spend time with sales staff, interview customers, and compare order dates with dispatch records. Suppose the students find that customers still want the product, but orders are being held while the credit team waits for information. The solution might be a clearer handover and an escalation rule. A dashboard could help the teams see which orders are stuck, but it would help because the students first understood what was holding them up.
Locating the cause requires knowledge. A finance student must know how to distinguish a credit risk from an administrative delay. A marketing student must know what evidence points to weaker demand. Someone studying operations must understand how work flows from one department to the next. The team must also know how to ask questions without putting people on the defensive. That combination of theory, observation and judgement is what I would want a management programme to teach and assess.
HyperBuild at Lexicon MILE as a practical learning example
At Lexicon MILE, the HyperBuild model starts with an organisation and the problems its people face. The programme describes live corporate challenges and the use of AI, automation and analytics. A team may build a dashboard or workflow after studying the problem with the people who do the work.
The assessment I would apply is the same as for any institute. Show the original brief, the diagnosis, each student’s contribution, what the host tested or used and, where available, what changed. A project may also be valuable when the evidence leads the team to recommend a simpler change in process.
The lab is one means of doing that work. A group can also create value by simplifying a process, changing how information is collected or redesigning a handover. The test is whether the organisation had a real problem, whether the students understood it and whether the proposed solution was useful. Sometimes a careful pilot shows that an idea will fail under conditions no one had considered. That finding can save an employer time and money and can show more judgement than a polished presentation of a proposal that has never been tried.
I want this kind of practice to run through the two years of an MBA or PGDM. Early on, a faculty member might take students through a case with enough information to recognise a pattern. Later, an employer can give them a brief where the underlying issue is still in dispute.
Students should map how the work happens, check their diagnosis against records and the experience of the people doing the work, then agree with the host on what improvement would look like. If the team builds something, it should test it with the intended users. If the work calls for a new process or a different way of assigning responsibility, the team should try that change on a small scale and see what happens.
In Pune and elsewhere in India, I would like institutes to show that an ordinary student gets this experience more than once before graduating. Ask to see how a team’s initial diagnosis changed, what it tested, and what the people using the solution said.
Why practical learning gets 50% of my institute assessment
In the capability-building index we have been developing, I would give 50 out of 100 points to practical learning. That weight expresses what I think a management programme should make students capable of doing. The 50 points break down as follows:
- 10 for identifying the real problem
- 15 for individual ownership and delivery
- 10 for testing and improving the solution
- 15 for demonstrating value to the organisation
The assessment should also show what share of the batch received work of comparable depth. A project involving a handful of exceptional students can illustrate the method. The reach of the method tells a parent what their own child is likely to experience.
The other 50 points matter because they support that work. I would allocate:
- 10 to curriculum
- 13 to faculty effectiveness and accessibility
- 10 to professional development
- 10 to mentoring and feedback
- 7 to career preparation and support after joining
The weighting gives an institute credit for the educational conditions it can build. To score the quality of delivery, I would look for actual work, assessed development, and host feedback. A website can tell me what is planned. A marked project and an employer’s account can tell me what happened.
I would apply this standard to Lexicon MILE and to every institute we evaluate. If an organisation confirms it adopted a solution, record adoption. If it also shows that processing time fell or errors were reduced, record the measured result and the conditions under which it was achieved. Where either piece of evidence is missing, leave that part unassessed.
The same standard should apply to an AI tool, a finance recommendation, an onboarding process or a supply-chain improvement. That is how I would make practical learning count without letting the format or the technology decide the score.
What to look for on a Pune business school campus visit
I would start with the curriculum, but I would ask to see what students are required to do with it. How often is it updated? Who contributes to those changes? Are students asked to make decisions from incomplete information? Do they have to justify those decisions to someone who can question their assumptions? If they use AI, do they know how to check the data, verify the result, and identify a situation where the tool gives a misleading answer? A good course should build knowledge deep enough for the student to explain what they did and why.
Faculty are central to that process. A skilled teacher can hear a confident presentation and still ask the question that reveals a weakness in the reasoning. A good project supervisor can help a student recognise what evidence is missing while leaving the student responsible for finding it. Before admission, I would ask who will actually teach the core subjects, how accessible faculty are outside class, and how they respond when a student is falling behind. A sample class and an anonymised set of comments on student work would tell me more about teaching than a list of visiting speakers.
I would examine internships and live projects in the same way. How much of the batch works on an assignment with a defined problem and an identified supervisor? Does the organisation provide access to the people and information needed to investigate it? Can each student explain what they were responsible for? Is there a review midway through the assignment, when the work can still be improved?
An institute should be able to show a completed project, the feedback received and what the student changed. A long internship can be valuable if the responsibilities grow. A shorter assignment can be equally instructive if it is demanding, well supervised, and completed to a clear standard.
Teamwork and professional conduct deserve the same attention as technical skills. Ask whether everyone in a group has to defend their contribution. Look for situations where students have to listen to colleagues, negotiate priorities, and deliver work on which someone else depends. Ask how the institute handles a missed deadline or a student who repeatedly leaves the work to others. A student should have a chance to learn from mistakes and to demonstrate improvement. That takes consistent faculty involvement and individual mentoring.
Finally, talk to a range of alumni. Ask about the work they actually did in their first year and about a situation in which their education helped them. Ask what they had to learn on the job, what surprised them, and what they would have wanted the institute to do differently. A conversation with an alumnus who changed roles or took time to find suitable work can be particularly informative. It can show whether the institute’s preparation travelled with the person past the first employer.
Which skill-based certifications add value to an MBA or PGDM?
I would ask every management institute what skills a student can independently demonstrate by graduation and which certifications help them develop those skills. A well-chosen certification gives a student a clear standard to work towards and a way to identify gaps. It can also give a future employer evidence of a skill the student can bring to a new role. That matters as much when a graduate is ready for a second or third job as it does at the first interview.
Take a finance student who pursues a certification in financial modelling. I would want that student to use the skill to build a cash-flow forecast for a business, explain the assumptions, and show what happens if customers pay later than expected. A student learning data analytics might investigate where orders are getting stuck, then build a dashboard that helps the operations team act. In both cases, the certification gives the student a structure for learning. The project shows whether the student can use that learning to solve a problem that matters to someone else.
Before admission, I would ask which certifications fit my intended role, what students must do to earn them, whether faculty help them apply the skill, and whether the cost is included in the fee. A supervised assessment or a project the student must defend gives a family something concrete to examine.
Within my index, I would look at the quality and relevance of these certifications under professional development. Where students apply a certified skill to a live problem, I would assess the work itself under practical learning. The longer-term return comes when graduates can use the skill at work, build on it as their responsibilities grow, and keep learning as tools and roles change.
What institutes should be willing to publish
I would like to see every management institute follow a graduating batch after placement day. Begin with the full graduating cohort and report how many sought employment, received offers and actually joined. Show the roles and the median fixed pay, with the period and the group covered by each figure.
Follow up at six, twelve and twenty-four months. Record employment, voluntary moves, employer-initiated exits and the people the institute could not reach. The unanswered surveys matter because they tell the reader how much of the batch the report represents.
After three and five years, ask about earnings, promotions and changes in responsibility. Gather employer feedback where graduates consent and publish the findings in aggregate. A practical review can begin with a small sample if the institute explains how it was chosen. Over time the aim should be to hear from people across the batch, including those who took longer to find work or whose careers followed a less straightforward path. I would put more weight on an honest account of that variation than on a page of carefully chosen success stories.
This information would also help institutes improve. They could see where graduates regularly face difficulties and whether changes to the curriculum or internship model help the next batch. Employers could describe the capabilities graduates bring and the ones they still need to learn. Students could ask for evidence that relates to their chosen specialisation and to the kind of work they want. Where the institute does not yet have the answers, it should say so and explain what it will measure next.
I want students and parents to keep asking about fees, salaries, and placement. They should also ask what a graduate will be able to do once the recruiting team has moved on to the next batch. Will the graduate know how to locate a problem, work with the people affected, take responsibility for a solution, and see it through? Can the institute show how an ordinary student learns to do that over two years?
If the fee is ₹15 lakh, ₹20 lakh, or ₹25 lakh, those questions deserve specific answers before a family pays it. The answers tell us what the student is buying and what the employer, the family, and the country may gain over the years that follow.
Frequently asked questions about MBA and PGDM ROI in Pune
1. Which Pune MBA or PGDM institute has the best ROI?
Start with your admission offers, total costs, and target roles. Compare each programme’s median pay and joining data for a named batch, then ask for graduate outcomes after one, three, and five years. The public sources cited here describe programmes and early outcomes. They cannot establish which of the seven delivers the highest five-year return.
2. Is Lexicon MILE worth shortlisting for a PGDM in Pune?
Shortlist it if you want to apply AI and analytics to business problems. Ask for a completed HyperBuild project, feedback from the organisation involved, and a placement breakdown for your preferred roles. Compare the evidence and full cost with your other offers before deciding.
3. Does a good placement package mean a good return on investment?
A placement package is the starting offer. Estimate your return from the extra income you actually earn over time compared with your next-best option, then account for the full cost of the programme, including income forgone while studying.
4. How can I compare placements across Pune management institutes?
Use reports for the exact programmes and graduating batches you are comparing. Ask for median fixed pay, the share of placement-seeking students who joined, role and location breakdowns, and the conditions attached to variable pay.
Source notes
[1] The Jobs Explorer Placement Services. Published commercial terms for recruitment clients.
[2] Enlist India. Employer recruitment services and contingency fee terms.
[3] International Labour Organization. General principles and operational guidelines for fair recruitment.

