When the degree could open the door, and what it takes to earn a place in the room today
Imagine two graduates walking into job interviews a generation apart. The first says, “I have an MBA/PGDM.” The interviewer hears a shorthand for something relatively scarce. Here is someone who has spent serious time studying how businesses work, who has probably had to defend a decision in a classroom, and who might be worth putting on a management training track. The second graduate says exactly the same thing. The interviewer asks, “Tell me about a problem you solved. What did you do when your original plan failed? Can you explain the result to someone outside your field?” The same qualification have prompted two different conversations.
The difference is easy to miss if we look only at admissions brochures. A family still sees a postgraduate degree, a graduation photograph and, with some luck, a respectable first salary. The employer sees a person who will inherit unfinished work, deal with colleagues under pressure and have to make decisions with limited information. The distance between those two pictures is where much of the disappointment with management education begins. A student can spend two years satisfying every academic requirement and still arrive at work unprepared for an ordinary Monday.
That gap raises a question for business schools. What does an MBA/PGDM graduate have to be able to do today for the qualification to carry weight? The answer starts with the purpose of postgraduate management education.
When management became a subject worth studying
The MBA began with a practical idea. Running an organisation calls for knowledge and judgment that can be studied, taught and developed. An enterprise can have a sound product and still run out of cash. It can have a talented sales force and promise more than its operations team can deliver. It can hire intelligent people and give them conflicting goals. Understanding how decisions in one part of an organisation affect the rest is a distinct skill. The MBA gave graduate students a place to learn it systematically.
Harvard Business School traces its MBA programme to 1908 and dates the adoption of the case method as its primary form of instruction to 1924. India took its own institutional steps several decades later. The Indian Institute of Management Calcutta, established in 1961, was the first IIM and was set up for postgraduate studies and research in management. These milestones show how deliberately management was developed as an area of study. It needed faculty, teaching methods and problems worth examining. [1, 2]
Consider what happens in a good case discussion. Everyone receives broadly the same facts. One student recommends raising prices to protect margins. Another expects the company to lose customers and argues that it should change how it serves them. A third asks whether the business has enough cash to wait for either decision to work. The class has to choose, explain the assumptions behind the choice and listen to objections. The value of the exercise lies in having to take a position and account for its consequences.
That kind of learning made sense to companies looking for people who could grow beyond a narrow technical role. Someone might have entered business school with a background in engineering or commerce and emerged able to read a balance sheet, understand why a distributor held back orders and recognise how an incentive plan could encourage the wrong behaviour. The concepts gave future managers a common language. Applying them helped students see where the interests of departments and people came into conflict.
Why three letters could do so much work
When credible postgraduate management programmes were relatively few, the qualification carried a powerful signal. A recruiter might know how a particular institute selected students, what it expected of them and how earlier graduates had performed. A line on a résumé could stand in for a great deal of information. In some hiring settings, that was enough to put a graduate in contention for a role that otherwise would have taken years of work experience to reach.
The qualification mattered partly because the opportunity to earn it was scarce and partly because employers associated it with preparation. A recruiter who had seen several alumni do well could reasonably expect something from the next batch. A student could borrow that confidence at the beginning of a career and then earn it through work. A lot of what families remembered as the value of the MBA/PGDM was this head start.
Employers cared about diligence, communication and judgment in those days too. The difference lay in how much they could infer from the qualification before meeting the candidate. Recruitment at a trusted campus, a structured management trainee programme and an established track record gave the degree considerable weight. Where that institutional confidence was high, the candidate had less to demonstrate upfront. As the number and variety of programmes increased, the same initials began to tell a recruiter less about what any one candidate had learned.
There is a useful warning in that history. Scarcity can make a qualification commercially valuable. It can also keep capable people out. Wider access to management education gave graduates in more cities, and families with fewer resources, a route into corporate and entrepreneurial work. That opportunity deserves to be protected. The educational challenge is to give students the substance that once made the credential so persuasive.
When the number of seats grew faster than trust
An institute can add a classroom and increase its intake within an admissions cycle. Developing faculty who can teach a case well, building relationships with companies willing to supervise students and earning a good placement track record can take years. That difference in speed matters. Where expansion happened faster than the capacity to teach and mentor, the same degree could come to represent very different experiences.
The Ministry of Education’s All India Survey on Higher Education gives a sense of how many people were graduating with an MBA. Responding institutions reported 2,04,782 MBA graduates in 2011–12, 2,32,265 in 2021–22, 2,43,981 in 2022–23 and about 2.8 lakh in 2023–24. The figures use the survey’s MBA programme category, with PGDM and other qualifications reported separately. They are based on institutional responses in each year. [8–11]
India was already producing more than two lakh reported MBA graduates annually by 2011–12. The subsequent increase helps explain why employers had more holders of the same credential to choose from. To understand how many applicants wanted the available seats, we need to look at admissions figures separately.
India’s management education market is uneven. Some programmes continue to attract far more qualified applicants than they can take. Others have to work harder to fill a batch, even in places where interest in management careers remains substantial. In Maharashtra’s 2025–26 MBA and MMS admissions, Hindustan Times reported, citing the state CET Cell, that 42,642 students secured admission and 10,867 seats remained vacant. Both figures matter. Tens of thousands of students wanted the qualification, while a substantial share of available capacity went unused. [3]
There are several reasons a student may pass on a seat. The fees may be difficult to justify, the available specialisation may have little appeal, or the jobs a campus attracts may offer little improvement over what the student can find directly. Some applicants may prefer to work and reapply. At the employer end, an increase in the number of MBA/PGDM graduates creates no automatic increase in desirable entry-level management roles. A company may be expanding and still have only a handful of openings for people it can afford to train.
The pressure to fill seats can affect what schools pay attention to. Admissions teams can easily advertise an additional specialisation, a corporate logo or a photograph of a visiting executive. The harder questions start after the student enrols. Who checks the quality of internships? How often does a student have to present an argument and respond to questions? What happens when a student repeatedly misses deadlines or submits a polished report without understanding its data? The answers reflect choices about teaching, class size and the time faculty have to give feedback.
The dilution becomes visible at graduation. A school has completed its semester calendar. The student has collected grades and certificates. The recruiter asks for an example of independent work, and what follows is a description of what the group did, with little detail about the candidate’s own contribution. A person can pass a system designed around attendance, exams and submissions while missing the practice that would help them handle that interview. When enough graduates have that experience, employers start asking for stronger evidence from everyone.
What employers have to establish for themselves
A recruiter hiring for a sales role might ask a candidate to review three months of data from a territory. In one month, the company shipped far more to its distributors than usual. The next month, orders dropped. The candidate has a choice. They can call it a demand problem, recommend more promotions and move to the next slide. Or they can ask whether products actually sold through to shops and consumers, whether certain distributors are holding excess stock and whether a previous push simply pulled future orders forward. The second approach gives the recruiter something concrete to evaluate.
A finance interviewer might give a candidate a profitable company and ask why it struggles to pay suppliers. The candidate needs to connect the income statement with cash collections, credit terms and inventory. For an operations role, an interviewer might ask why dispatches are missing their promised date even though the warehouse has enough staff. The useful questions could concern when orders are released, how often priorities change and where errors create repeat work. The interview becomes a small sample of how the candidate will think on the job.
The Graduate Management Admission Council’s 2026 Corporate Recruiters Survey draws on responses from more than 620 recruiters and staffing-firm hiring managers around the world. Problem-solving, communication and strategic thinking ranked among the skills employers valued most across regions. Respondents also expected the ability to use AI tools to rise in importance over the following five years. For a school, the implication is practical. A student ought to be able to investigate a problem, explain the decision, and use the available tools well enough to improve the work. [4]
Questions about attitude and hard work belong in this conversation because entry-level managers are paid to follow through. Consider a student who discovers, late in a project, that two team members have calculated the same metric using different definitions. A future manager wants to know what happens next. Does the student raise the problem promptly, agree on a definition and rerun the analysis? Can they explain what changed without blaming a colleague? The way the candidate handles that ordinary setback says something about how much responsibility they can be trusted with.
Attitude is something a school can teach
In an interview, “good attitude” can be an imprecise description for someone the interviewer happens to like. A business school can give the term more meaning by making it about behaviour that people actually observe. A student shows reliability by delivering what they agreed to do or warning the team in time to change the plan. They show curiosity by asking how a customer actually uses a product. They show humility by changing their mind when new evidence arrives. They show initiative by spotting work that needs doing and taking responsibility for it.
Hard work also needs a practical definition. A student may spend the whole night fixing a presentation while the team’s central assumption goes untested. Another student may spend an hour calling three people who know the process, discover the assumption is wrong and save the team a week. There are times when a difficult job simply takes stamina. Good training also teaches people to direct that effort, keep promises and finish work to a standard someone else can rely on.
These habits take repeated practice. In a team assignment, the faculty member can ask each person to keep a record of commitments and exchange specific feedback with peers. A student who joined late to three meetings needs to hear how it affected the work. Someone who kept finishing other people’s tasks may need to learn how to delegate and raise problems earlier. Another student might have had the best idea but withheld it because a more confident classmate dominated the conversation. Each has a different skill to practise before the next assignment.
Attitude shows up in the way students manage conflict. A classmate gives a blunt critique of an analysis. The analyst can treat that as a personal slight, accept it automatically, or ask the classmate to identify the assumption they think is weak. The third response can turn a tense exchange into better work. An institute can make that response easier to learn by giving students more than one chance to revise an assignment after feedback. One graded submission tells a teacher where a student stood that day. A revision shows what the student does with instruction.
The same habits transfer to other parts of life. A graduate might have to negotiate a delivery problem in a family business, make a financial decision at home, organise volunteers or help a colleague through a difficult transition. Listening carefully, checking an assumption, explaining a trade-off and keeping one’s word are useful in all of those situations. The school can start developing them in a classroom. Graduates will keep using them long after they forget the details of a particular case.
English proficiency is a working skill
English matters in many Indian workplaces because it is often the shared language across locations and teams. A junior manager may have to write to a customer, explain a decision to a colleague in another state, participate in a video call or send a summary that senior managers can act on. Clear communication can prevent a costly misunderstanding. The listener needs to know what happened, what is still uncertain and what decision is required.
Imagine a graduate giving an update on a delayed order. A vague message says the team is working on the issue and will revert soon. A useful update says the order is held up because an item failed inspection, a replacement will arrive on Thursday, and the customer needs to choose between accepting a partial delivery on Wednesday and waiting for the full order on Friday. The vocabulary is ordinary. The clarity comes from knowing which facts matter and what the reader needs to do.
This is where an MBA/PGDM can make a real difference for a student whose schooling gave them fewer opportunities to use English. A programme can start with a short diagnostic and give students weekly practice writing emails, explaining charts, running meetings and responding to follow-up questions. It can give the student who understands the numbers time to rehearse how to explain them. It can teach the student who speaks comfortably to listen, summarise an objection fairly and use fewer words. Improvement needs to be visible before placement week, when the pressure is already high.
Recruiters have a responsibility here as well. An accent tells an interviewer very little about whether someone can explain a complex issue to a customer. A rehearsed introduction also offers limited evidence. A short written exercise or a realistic role-play gives the candidate a fairer opportunity to demonstrate proficiency. In India, the ability to move between English and another language can be an advantage. The person who can understand a shop-floor concern in Marathi and explain its operational implications to colleagues elsewhere is doing work that a vocabulary test would barely capture.
The most useful skill starts with finding the problem
Students are often handed a problem that someone else has already defined. They are told to increase sales, cut waste or improve engagement. A manager’s work often starts one step earlier, when people disagree on what is actually going wrong. A business can spend months solving the wrong problem because the first explanation sounded obvious and nobody tested it.
Take a hypothetical fitness centre in Pune. Attendance at its 7 a.m. class has declined. The team suspects pricing and suggests a discount. A group of management students has four weeks to investigate. They split the attendance data by time slot and membership cohort, speak with people who left the class, and watch how new members book a session. They find that evening attendance has held up, morning members began dropping out after a timetable change, and several newer members had trouble finding the right class in the booking app.
The team now has reasons to test a narrower response. Restore a more predictable schedule, improve the booking instructions and see whether people return. Decide in advance what should count as success. Compare repeat attendance and overall visits so that a shift from one class to another does not look like new demand. Give the centre manager enough information to decide whether to keep the change when the students leave.
A simple project can teach several disciplines at once. Marketing helps students talk to members and understand what they value. Operations helps them see how timetable changes affect capacity and staffing. Finance helps them calculate what improvement would justify the cost. A statistics class helps them ask how much confidence to place in a small sample. Organisational behaviour helps them understand why a manager or coach might resist a proposed fix. The subjects become connected because the students have one decision to make.
There is also a lesson in how carefully people should describe their contribution. Suppose attendance improves after the timetable change, but a competing centre also happened to close for repairs. A good team reports both facts and explains the limits of the comparison. Management requires judgment in imperfect conditions, and honest conclusions give an organisation a better basis for its next decision. Students should have to defend those conclusions in front of people who can ask difficult questions.
The principle applies well beyond a gym. In a manufacturing company, a reported quality issue may stem from how shifts measure rejects. In a retailer, a falling sales chart may reflect out-of-stock days. In a service operation, a surge in customer complaints may concern a policy change the company failed to explain. In each case, the student should learn to go where the work happens, speak to the people who do it and check whether the numbers describe the same thing everyone is talking about.
What a skill-based MBA/PGDM would look like
A strong programme begins with a clear idea of what a graduate should be able to do independently. A finance student should be able to trace a cash shortfall, build a defensible forecast and explain its risks. A marketing student should be able to interview customers, identify a segment, design an experiment and measure the result. An operations student should be able to map a workflow and identify a constraint. Every graduate should practise giving feedback, writing a decision memo and making a recommendation under ordinary time pressure.
These abilities can be developed in stages. Early in the programme, students can tackle a well-designed case, learn the fundamentals and receive detailed feedback in a setting where the consequences of an error are small. Next, they can work with a company on a bounded problem with usable records and access to employees. Later, they can take responsibility for a pilot and see what happens when a recommendation meets a real budget, an existing workflow and people with reasons to question it.
A project needs a sponsor who can explain the problem and answer questions, a faculty guide who can spot weaknesses in the thinking, and an agreement on what students may do with the data. Without that structure, an assignment can become a handful of surveys and a slide deck no one uses. An employer who can spare only two hours may still contribute by giving students a carefully chosen problem and attending a final review. Schools can design projects around the time their partners genuinely have.
Use the assessment to expose the learning. Ask students who did the work to take turns explaining it under questioning. Give them a second dataset with a different pattern and see whether they can adapt. Have each student identify a decision they made and a mistake they would correct. Record whether a student needed substantial help and whether their work improved after feedback. Alongside the final grade, this gives the graduate examples they can talk about honestly in a job interview.
The habits developed in one semester should show up in the next. When a student takes a finance elective after a basic communications module, they can be asked to explain a sensitivity analysis to someone who has never built a forecast. When a marketing student takes a pricing project, they should be able to explain what it does to gross margin and capacity. This requires faculty to coordinate expectations. It also makes the programme feel like an education in managing an organisation, where the work rarely arrives with a subject code attached.
Ask employers first and certify what students can do
A practical way to update the MBA/PGDM is to ask organisations what they need graduates to do in their first six months. Speak to the manager who will supervise them as well as the recruiter. Ask what assignments new hires handle, which tools they use and where they typically need help. If finance managers say graduates struggle to reconcile data or explain variances, build those tasks into the training and ask employers to review the assessment.
The certifications should follow the work. For reporting roles, examples include Microsoft Office Specialist Excel Expert and Microsoft Certified Power BI Data Analyst Associate (PL-300). A finance pathway can offer an assessed certificate in financial modelling and valuation. A marketing pathway can prepare students for Google Analytics Certification through Skillshop, alongside a campaign measurement exercise. An operations pathway could include Lean Six Sigma Green Belt training with a supervised process improvement project. Each school should say who issues the credential and what the student must complete to earn it. Students should know whether external exam fees are included in their tuition costs. [5–7]
A student who earns a Power BI credential should also be able to show how a dashboard exposed a sales or inventory issue and what decision it supported. That exercise gives the employer something to discuss. When companies return the following year, ask whether the training helped graduates do the work with less supervision.
Tools have raised the standard for judgment
A graduating student should be comfortable with the tools used in the roles they want. A spreadsheet is a place to inspect assumptions, clean data and show someone how a result was calculated. A dashboard is useful when it helps a manager decide what needs attention. Generative AI can help a team explore explanations for a change in customer behaviour or draft questions for interviews. In each case, students need to develop the judgment to spot a weak answer and the discipline to check the work before relying on it.
Imagine a team asks an AI tool to explain a decline in regional revenue. The answer proposes a change in customer preferences and recommends a new marketing campaign. A closer look at the records shows that the company lost a major account and booked the previous year’s order across two months. The suggested campaign may have sounded plausible, but it followed from a diagnosis the team could disprove. A faculty member can ask students to document the checks they performed and have them defend their reasoning using the underlying records.
The same assignment can expose the limits of a polished presentation. Ask the student to trace a figure from the slide back to the source data. Change one assumption, hand the student a whiteboard and ask how the recommendation changes. Ask what information the company can share with an external tool and who is authorised to make that decision. These are questions about responsibility. A manager will remain accountable when the chart, email or recommendation generated by a tool causes someone else to take action.
Placement day is one point on a longer timeline
The first salary matters. Many families borrow or use years of savings to pay fees, and a student who receives a credible offer has something concrete to show for that investment. Yet two graduates with similar packages can have very different starts. One gets regular feedback, learns to deal with clients and earns a wider remit after a year. The other spends months in a role that was described differently during recruitment and leaves with little evidence of what they accomplished. The placement figures may record the same kind of success before those stories diverge.
Even a careful reader of the placement report needs the right questions. The highest package describes the top offer. The median tells you where the middle of the reported group falls, provided the school tells you whose offers it counted. Ask how many students entered the batch, participated in placement and accepted offers. Ask how the advertised compensation is divided between fixed pay, variable pay and one-time components. Then look at the jobs themselves. A role has a manager, a set of responsibilities, expectations for the first six months and a path for learning. Those details help a student judge which offer is worth taking.
A longer view of return on investment asks what graduates can do one or three years later. Are they still in work they want to pursue? Have they earned greater responsibility, led an improvement or solved a problem their manager cared about? Do peers seek their input? Can they move into a different kind of role if the market changes? Someone may leave a first employer for a better opportunity, a family commitment or because the role was a poor fit. A useful alumni survey would capture those distinctions before drawing conclusions from retention figures.
Schools cannot determine what happens in every graduate’s career. They can gather more evidence about the transition into work. Speak to alumni about what surprised them in the first ninety days. Ask supervisors what new hires can already do and where they need more guidance. Share recurring themes with faculty and make visible changes to the curriculum. If several graduates say they could build a financial model but struggled to defend assumptions in a room of senior colleagues, the school has a specific problem it can address.
What applicants in Pune can look for
A prospective student visiting a campus can ask to sit through an ordinary class. Watch how much of the session belongs to students, how the teacher handles a disagreement and what happens when an assertion needs evidence. Ask to see a sample project brief and learn how the school assessed the work. A candid conversation with a recent graduate about a difficult assignment may reveal more than a guided tour.
Pune gives schools several kinds of operating environments to draw on. A faculty member can use the buying process at a manufacturing supplier, a retail inventory problem or the handover between teams at a technology company to connect local business activity with classroom topics. Ask how often students get such exposure, what proportion of the batch takes part and what they are asked to deliver. The strength of an industry connection shows up in what students do with it.
Applicants can also bring their own weaknesses to the discussion. A student who wants to work in finance but has little experience with accounting can ask what support is available in the first term. Someone who freezes while speaking English in a group can ask how often students practise and get individual feedback. A graduate with prior work experience can ask how the programme will stretch them beyond work they have already done. Each is asking the school to show where personal improvement will happen and who will notice it.
Students have obligations of their own. In team projects they can volunteer for work that exposes a weakness, rather than dividing tasks so that everyone does what they already know. Someone comfortable with numbers can conduct an interview and write up the findings. A persuasive speaker can reconcile the data behind the team’s recommendation. Both should be able to answer for the full project. The point of paying for an education is to leave able to do work that once felt beyond reach.
Bringing the MBA/PGDM back to its purpose
The need of the hour is to develop day zero professionals. A day zero professional arrives ready to contribute from the start. Give them a brief, and they can clarify what is expected, organise their work, ask for the information they need and give an update someone can act on. They will still need to learn the company’s systems and earn the trust of colleagues. Their manager can spend time teaching them how the business works because the graduate knows how to take feedback, meet a deadline and raise a problem before it becomes a crisis.
Consider how different graduation would feel if the student carried a portfolio alongside the degree. One piece could be a short memo showing how they diagnosed a customer problem. Another could be a model with the assumptions and risks explained. A third might record what they changed after a supervisor rejected their first proposal. These modest pieces of work can reveal the judgment, effort and learning habits that a single exam score compresses. They also give a graduate a credible way to describe their value in the first interview.
The earliest MBA programmes treated management as work that could be learned through study and practice. The degree became valuable because people trusted what a graduate had done to earn it. As management education expanded, the certificate remained easy to recognise while the preparation behind it became harder to infer. Schools can restore confidence by giving students more chances to investigate a real problem, make a decision and accept responsibility for what follows.
Return to those two candidates. The first could say “I have an MBA/PGDM” and expect the interviewer to understand much of what the qualification meant. The second has to explain it in terms the employer can judge. There is a good answer available. “Here is the problem we found. Here is what I did. Here is where I was wrong, and here is what we changed.” A business school earns the value of its qualification when its graduates can have that conversation with confidence and honesty.
Sources
- Harvard Business School history
- IIM Calcutta institutional history
- Hindustan Times reporting on Maharashtra MBA and MMS admissions for 2025–26
- GMAC Corporate Recruiters Survey 2026
- Microsoft Office Specialist Excel Expert
- Microsoft Power BI Data Analyst Associate
- Google Skillshop
- AISHE 2011–12 programme-wise pass-outs, Table 35
- AISHE 2021–22 programme-wise pass-outs, Table 34
- AISHE 2022–23 programme-wise MBA pass-outs
- AISHE 2023–24 programme-wise out-turn, section 2.7.3

